Experience the Future of Amazon Legal Assistance Today. Try our AI paralegal START NOW
For anyone starting in e-commerce, deciding where to sell your products online is a critical step. The platform you choose impacts your brand’s visibility, customer base, operational complexity, and legal obligations. In this article, we’ll explore six popular options: Amazon, eBay, Etsy, Walmart Marketplace, Shopify, and independent online stores. We’ll talk about the pros and cons of each platform, discuss the types of sellers they are best suited for, and examine the legal considerations associated with them. We’ve also included a detailed comparison chart to help you evaluate these platforms at a glance.
Amazon is the go-to platform for many sellers due to its enormous audience, providing unmatched access to potential customers through its robust infrastructure. Sellers benefit from tools like Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA), which handles storage, shipping, and customer service, allowing them to focus on growing their business.
Active users: 310 million
Active Sellers: 2 million
Few platforms can match the sheer number of active users on Amazon, providing an unparalleled opportunity to reach potential buyers worldwide.
Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) takes care of storage, packaging, shipping, and even customer service, freeing up time for sellers to focus on scaling their operations.
Amazon’s trusted name boosts customer confidence, leading to higher conversion rates for your products.
Amazon offers a variety of advertising options, including Sponsored Products, Sponsored Brands, and display ads, to help you increase visibility and drive sales.
With Amazon operating in multiple countries, sellers can expand into international markets relatively quickly using Amazon’s infrastructure and global reach.
Amazon supports a wide variety of product categories, making it suitable for almost any type of seller, from electronics to handmade goods.
The platform’s popularity means sellers often face competition from other third-party sellers and even Amazon itself, which sometimes offers competing products under its private label brands.
Amazon’s complex fee system includes referral fees, FBA costs, and additional charges for long-term storage or high-volume inventory. These fees can significantly reduce profit margins.
Amazon’s rules and algorithms are unforgiving. Even minor policy violations can result in account suspensions, which are often challenging and time-consuming to resolve.
Sellers have limited opportunities to build a unique brand presence on Amazon, as the platform’s structure prioritizes product listings over branding.
Using FBA requires careful inventory planning to avoid overstocking (leading to storage fees) or running out of stock (hurting your rankings).
Amazon customers often have high expectations for shipping speed, product quality, and customer service, which can put pressure on sellers to meet these standards consistently.
Amazon keeps tight control over customer data, limiting your ability to build a direct relationship with buyers or remarket to them outside the platform.
Sellers must constantly monitor their Account Health metrics, including customer feedback and performance indicators, to avoid penalties or account suspension.
Selling on Amazon often involves following policies and guidelines intended to protect consumers and support fair competition. While not all measures are mandatory, failing to meet certain expectations may lead to account suspension, financial penalties, or even legal consequences. Key considerations include:
Registering trademarks, copyrights, and patents protects your brand and prevents unauthorized use. Amazon’s Brand Registry helps sellers guard against counterfeiters and hijackers, while regular monitoring ensures listings remain secure.
Product safety standards depend on the product type. For example, Electronics must follow proper safety guidelines, children’s products require careful adherence to protective measures, and consumables must meet strict rules for ingredients and labeling.
Amazon’s anti-counterfeiting measures demand proof of authenticity, such as invoices and manufacturer documentation. Programs like Transparency and Project Zero enable sellers to authenticate products and address counterfeit claims quickly.
For international sellers, compliance with local laws is essential. This includes import/export regulations, regional safety standards, and tax obligations like VAT or sales tax. Preparation and documentation are key to avoiding fines and disruptions.
By safeguarding intellectual property, ensuring product compliance, and leveraging Amazon tools like Brand Registry and Transparency, sellers can meet Amazon’s legal standards and maintain their competitive edge.
eBay appeals to sellers seeking simplicity and flexibility and is known for its auction-style listings, making it a great choice for selling used, rare, or one-of-a-kind items. While it doesn’t have Amazon’s massive audience, it offers lower entry barriers and greater flexibility, making it ideal for smaller operations or niche sellers.
Active users: 132 million
Active Sellers: 19 million
Sellers can choose between auction-style listings, which are ideal for rare or collectible items, and fixed-price listings, suitable for standard products. This flexibility allows sellers to experiment with pricing strategies.
eBay is one of the easiest platforms to get started with. The setup process is straightforward, and there are no stringent seller approval processes.
eBay facilitates international selling, enabling sellers to reach buyers from around the world. This is particularly beneficial for niche or rare items that appeal to a global audience.
eBay supports a wide variety of product categories, from electronics to antiques, making it a versatile platform for different types of sellers.
Sellers are not tied to long-term contracts or obligations, offering the flexibility to scale up or down as needed.
eBay attracts buyers specifically looking for deals or unique finds, making it a good platform for clearing out overstocked or secondhand inventory.
Unlike some platforms, eBay is well-known for used and refurbished products, offering an established market for sellers in this category.
Unlike Amazon, eBay lacks robust advertising and promotional tools, which can make it challenging to increase visibility for your products.
While eBay is a trusted name, buyers may approach the platform with more caution, especially for higher-value purchases, due to concerns about counterfeit or low-quality items.
eBay charges fees for both listing items and completed sales. Additionally, payment processing fees through platforms like PayPal can further reduce profit margins.
eBay’s buyer-friendly policies can sometimes leave sellers vulnerable in disputes. Resolving complaints, handling returns, or addressing negative feedback can be time-consuming and costly.
eBay’s low entry barriers mean sellers often face competition from those offering lower-quality or counterfeit goods, which can dilute buyer trust.
While great for small operations, eBay may not be as scalable as platforms like Amazon or Shopify, particularly for sellers looking to establish a strong brand presence.
Unlike Amazon’s FBA, eBay does not offer integrated fulfillment options. Sellers must manage shipping, packaging, and returns independently, which can be time-intensive.
Selling on eBay requires attention to key legal areas, including:
eBay strictly prohibits counterfeit goods. Sellers must maintain documentation such as invoices and manufacturer certifications to prove their items’ authenticity. Sourcing products from trusted suppliers and performing quality checks are essential to avoid penalties.
eBay enforces IP rights through its Verified Rights Owner (VeRO) program, which protects trademarks, copyrights, and patents. Avoid using unauthorized branded materials or infringing content, and ensure your products are legitimate and authorized for resale to prevent takedowns or disputes.
For international trade, sellers must comply with customs laws, provide accurate documentation, and avoid restricted items in destination countries. Failing to meet these requirements can result in delays or fines. Research trade laws for each country you ship to and align your listings with local regulations.
eBay’s buyer-friendly policies can be challenging. To protect yourself, provide clear descriptions, use accurate images, and document transactions thoroughly. Quick communication and proof of delivery can help resolve conflicts in your favor.
By prioritizing authenticity, respecting IP rights, and adhering to trade laws, sellers can avoid legal issues and thrive on eBay. Leverage eBay’s VeRO program and seller resources to stay compliant and protect your business.
Etsy has established itself as the go-to platform for artisans, crafters, and sellers of vintage and handmade items. With its specialized audience that values creativity and uniqueness, Etsy provides an ideal marketplace for sellers whose products don’t fit into the typical mass-market categories. However, its niche focus means it may not be suitable for everyone.
Active users: 95 million
Active Sellers: 7.5 million
Etsy attracts buyers who are specifically searching for unique, handmade, or vintage items. This audience often values creativity and originality, giving artisans a direct path to the right customers.
Setting up and managing an Etsy store is simple, even for sellers with limited technical skills. The platform provides easy-to-use templates and built-in tools to streamline the process.
Etsy fosters a strong sense of community among its sellers and provides resources like forums, workshops, and guides tailored to creative businesses.
Etsy’s reputation as the marketplace for handmade and creative goods draws a steady stream of shoppers, reducing the need for sellers to invest heavily in traffic generation.
Etsy allows sellers to create detailed, visually appealing product listings with multiple photos, videos, and story elements that resonate with buyers.
Etsy offers tools for international sales, including currency conversion and language translation, allowing sellers to reach a broader audience.
Etsy actively markets itself as a champion of small businesses, aligning with buyers who value supporting independent sellers.
Etsy charges listing fees (currently $0.20 per item), transaction fees (6.5% of each sale), and payment processing fees, which can quickly add up and reduce profit margins.
Etsy’s niche audience and strict product guidelines may restrict growth for sellers aiming to expand into broader markets or mass production.
Only handmade items, vintage goods (at least 20 years old), and craft supplies are allowed. Sellers who want to offer more general products may find these restrictions limiting.
While Etsy’s audience is specialized, it’s also competitive. New sellers may find it difficult to stand out among established stores with strong reviews and a loyal customer base.
Although Etsy allows some customization, the platform’s layout and branding prioritize the marketplace over individual stores, making it harder to establish a distinct brand identity.
As with other marketplaces, sellers are subject to Etsy’s changing policies. Any updates or fee increases can directly impact profitability.
Handmade and custom products often require more time and effort to produce, which can make scaling inventory challenging as demand increases.
Etsy sellers face distinct legal challenges, particularly around:
Many handmade or designed items risk copyright or design infringement claims, either from competitors or unintentional use of protected materials. To avoid disputes, sellers should ensure their creations are original and thoroughly research similar listings.
Products like toys, candles, or cosmetics often fall under strict safety and labeling regulations, which vary by region. Items may require certifications, such as ASTM or CE for toys, or clear ingredient disclosures for cosmetics. Sellers should comply with these standards to prevent fines, product bans, or liability issues.
For international shipping, sellers must adhere to customs laws, including material restrictions, accurate declarations, and duties or taxes like VAT. Non-compliance can result in delays, confiscated goods, or penalties.
By ensuring product originality, meeting safety standards, and following trade regulations, Etsy sellers can avoid legal issues and maintain trust with their customers.
Walmart Marketplace’s growing online presence and relatively low competition make it an appealing option for established sellers looking to diversify their revenue streams. Offering access to Walmart’s extensive customer base and the credibility associated with its well-known brand, it has quickly positioned itself as a serious alternative to Amazon.
Active users: 120 million unique visitors per month.
Active Sellers: 150,000
Compared to Amazon, Walmart Marketplace is less saturated, giving sellers greater visibility and reducing the pressure to compete with an overwhelming number of listings.
Walmart’s reputation as a trusted retailer adds credibility to your products, making it easier to win the confidence of customers, especially for higher-priced or essential items.
Walmart’s referral fee structure is straightforward, with no additional listing or monthly subscription fees. This simplicity can make it easier to calculate and manage costs.
Walmart’s brick-and-mortar presence attracts loyal customers who are increasingly shopping online, giving sellers a hybrid audience of traditional and digital shoppers.
Similar to Amazon, Walmart features a Buy Box-style system, enabling competitive pricing strategies that can lead to more sales.
Walmart’s fulfillment services provide benefits similar to Amazon’s FBA, such as faster shipping, inventory management, and improved customer satisfaction.
Walmart’s audience is particularly strong in categories like groceries, household goods, and everyday essentials, making it an excellent platform for sellers in these niches.
Walmart vets its sellers rigorously, requiring businesses to demonstrate a track record of success, reliable fulfillment processes, and high-quality products. This makes it harder for new or small sellers to join.
While Walmart has improved its advertising options, they are not as advanced or comprehensive as Amazon’s suite of tools. Sellers have fewer opportunities to boost visibility through promotions or sponsored listings.
Walmart is better suited to businesses with existing operational capacity. New or small-scale sellers may struggle to meet the platform’s standards or gain traction.
Walmart’s emphasis on competitive pricing can put pressure on sellers to lower prices, potentially impacting profit margins.
Walmart’s customer base often prioritizes value over premium branding, making it harder for high-end or boutique sellers to thrive on the platform.
Walmart closely monitors seller performance metrics like shipping speed, product quality, and customer satisfaction. Falling short of these standards can lead to penalties or account removal.
Unlike Amazon, Walmart’s marketplace is primarily U.S.-focused, which can be a drawback for sellers targeting global markets.
Selling on Walmart Marketplace requires strict compliance with:
Walmart enforces rigorous rules for products, especially in regulated categories like electronics, toys, and health-related items. Sellers must ensure items meet safety certifications, proper labeling, and quality standards to avoid penalties or listing removal.
Similar to Amazon’s Brand Registry, the Walmart Brand Portal provides brand owners with tools to protect their intellectual property and maintain brand integrity. By registering their trademarks, sellers can identify and address potential violations, ensuring that only authorized sellers represent their products.
Walmart prioritizes performance metrics, including timely delivery, accurate product descriptions, and high customer satisfaction. Failure to meet these standards can result in penalties, reduced visibility, or suspension. Clear communication and prompt fulfillment are essential to maintaining compliance.
Sellers must accurately collect and report state and local taxes, even in cases where Walmart remits them on the seller’s behalf. Non-compliance can lead to financial penalties or account suspension.
By ensuring product compliance, meeting performance standards, and adhering to tax laws, sellers can maintain a strong presence on Walmart Marketplace while avoiding legal or platform-related consequences.
Shopify is a popular choice for entrepreneurs who want to take full control of their online store. Unlike marketplace platforms, Shopify allows sellers to create their own unique e-commerce website, offering customizable design templates, marketing integrations, and a suite of tools for managing orders, payments, and shipping. Shopify empowers sellers to control their customer relationships and data, making it an attractive option for brand-focused businesses.
Shopify gives sellers full control over their store’s design, branding, and functionality. You can create a fully customized shopping experience that reflects your brand’s identity, free from marketplace limitations.
Shopify offers plans and tools to support businesses at every stage, from startups to large enterprises. Features like Shopify Plus cater to high-volume sellers, while smaller plans are perfect for new businesses.
Unlike marketplaces, Shopify stores stand alone. You won’t be competing directly with other sellers on the same platform or dealing with “Buy Box” wars.
Shopify integrates with thousands of apps, enabling sellers to enhance their store with tools for SEO, email marketing, dropshipping, and more.
Shopify makes it easy to sell across multiple channels, including social media platforms like Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok, as well as physical point-of-sale (POS) systems.
Shopify supports multiple languages, currencies, and payment gateways, allowing you to cater to international customers seamlessly.
Shopify’s checkout process can be optimized to improve conversion rates, with options for upselling, personalized recommendations, and abandoned cart recovery.
Shopify provides access to extensive resources, tutorials, and a vibrant community of entrepreneurs and experts to help sellers succeed.
Unlike marketplaces with built-in audiences, Shopify requires sellers to drive their own traffic through marketing efforts like SEO, paid ads, and social media. This can be challenging for those without prior experience.
Shopify’s subscription fees range from $29 to $299 per month (and more for Shopify Plus), with additional costs for premium apps, themes, and payment processing fees. These expenses can add up quickly.
While Shopify is user-friendly, creating and customizing a store requires time and effort, particularly for sellers unfamiliar with website design or e-commerce tools.
Sellers are entirely responsible for logistics, inventory management, and customer support. Without tools like Amazon’s FBA, this adds operational complexity.
If you don’t use Shopify Payments, additional transaction fees apply. This can be a downside for businesses relying on alternative gateways like PayPal or Stripe.
Sellers must ensure their store complies with data privacy regulations, like GDPR or CCPA, which can be complex for those targeting international audiences.
While there’s no direct platform competition, you may face significant challenges competing with larger, well-established brands in your niche.
With Shopify, sellers are responsible for ensuring compliance with various legal requirements, including:
Regulations such as GDPR (for European customers) and CCPA (for California residents) mandate secure handling of customer data, including privacy policies and opt-in features for data collection.
Your site must adhere to accessibility standards, such as ADA compliance in the U.S., to ensure it is usable by people with disabilities. Non-compliance can lead to legal consequences.
Protecting your intellectual property is critical since Shopify stores are brand-driven. Trademarks, copyrights, and patents should be properly registered to safeguard your brand identity and product designs.
Independent stores must comply with regional and international e-commerce laws, including accurate product labeling, transparent return policies, and proper sales tax collection and reporting.
Ensuring secure payment processing through PCI-compliant gateways is critical to protect both your business and your customers from fraud or data breaches.
If you sell globally, you must adhere to import/export regulations and manage tax collection across different regions.
Building your own independent online store offers unparalleled freedom to design, manage, and grow your business without relying on third-party platforms. By creating a standalone website, you gain complete control over branding, customer relationships, and pricing strategies. While this approach demands significant effort and investment upfront, it can lead to greater long-term growth and independence for your business.
You have complete control over every aspect of your store, including its design, user experience, pricing, and policies. This freedom allows you to create a tailored shopping experience that aligns with your brand values and customer expectations.
Unlike marketplaces or e-commerce platforms that charge commissions or monthly fees, running your own store eliminates these costs. Once your website is set up, ongoing expenses are primarily tied to hosting and maintenance.
Your independent store is entirely focused on your brand. Unlike marketplaces where your products compete for attention, your website highlights your unique offerings without distractions.
With an independent store, you can scale your business at your own pace, adding features, categories, or regions as your business grows.
Selling through your own store allows you to collect valuable customer data, build a mailing list, and foster direct relationships, which can lead to repeat business and higher lifetime customer value.
You can integrate any tools or features you need, from advanced analytics to personalized recommendations, creating a shopping experience that’s tailored to your audience.
Unlike marketplaces where you share the space with competitors, your store is exclusively focused on your products, eliminating competition from other sellers.
Setting up and maintaining an independent store requires a significant time and resource commitment. Tasks such as building the website, designing the user experience, and setting up payment and shipping systems can be overwhelming, especially for beginners.
Without the built-in audience of a marketplace, you’re entirely responsible for driving traffic to your store. This often requires ongoing investment in SEO, social media, paid advertising, and content marketing.
Running an independent store means managing hosting, website security, software updates, and troubleshooting technical issues. Without technical expertise, these tasks can become a major hurdle.
While you save on marketplace fees, launching your own store involves upfront expenses for website development, hosting, domain registration, and potential professional services for design or technical support.
Independent stores don’t benefit from the brand trust of established platforms like Amazon or eBay. Gaining customer confidence requires significant effort, such as showcasing reviews, offering secure payment methods, and providing excellent customer service.
Expanding internationally requires managing taxes, shipping logistics, and currency conversions, which can add layers of complexity compared to platforms that offer these solutions natively.
Running an independent store means taking full responsibility for complying with various legal requirements, including:
Regulations such as GDPR and CCPA mandate secure handling of customer data, including privacy policies and opt-in features for data collection.
Your site must adhere to accessibility standards, such as ADA compliance in the U.S., to ensure it is usable by people with disabilities. Non-compliance can lead to legal consequences.
Protecting your trademarks, copyrights, and patents is crucial to prevent competitors from infringing on your brand identity or product designs.
Independent stores must comply with regional and international e-commerce laws, including accurate product labeling, transparent return policies, and proper sales tax collection and reporting.
Ensuring secure payment processing through PCI-compliant gateways is critical to protect both your business and your customers from fraud or data breaches.
If you sell globally, you’ll need to manage customs documentation, tariffs, and prohibited item restrictions for each target market.
Below is a chart summarizing the key aspects of each platform to help you decide which one aligns with your business goals.
| Platform | Audience Size | Ease of Setup | Fees | Brand Control | Competition Level | Legal Complexity | Best For |
| Amazon | Massive | Moderate | High | Low | High | High | High-volume sellers seeking scale |
| eBay | Moderate | Easy | Moderate | Low | Moderate | Moderate | Small-scale sellers or unique items |
| Etsy | Niche | Easy | Moderate-High | Moderate | Moderate | Moderate | Artisans and creatives |
| Walmart Marketplace | Growing | Difficult | Moderate | Low | Low | High | Established sellers diversifying |
| Shopify | Depends on Marketing | Moderate | Subscription-based | High | None | Moderate-High | Entrepreneurs building a brand |
| Independent Online Store | Depends on Marketing | Difficult | Varys | High | None | High | Sellers seeking full control |
Choosing the right e-commerce platform depends on your goals, product type, and willingness to handle legal responsibilities. For access to a massive audience, Amazon and Walmart are excellent choices but come with strict compliance requirements. Etsy caters to niche markets, while eBay offers flexibility for smaller-scale operations. Shopify and independent stores provide control and branding opportunities but require greater effort to build and maintain.
No matter where you choose to sell, consulting with legal experts ensures you’re compliant and well-prepared for potential challenges, setting your business up for long-term success.
Legal Disclaimer:
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Laws and regulations may change, and they can vary by jurisdiction and over time. For advice tailored to your specific situation, please consult a qualified legal professional.
Legal Disclaimer: The articles published on our platform are for informational purposes only and do not constitute legal advice in any form. They are not intended to be a substitute for professional legal counsel. For any legal matters, it is essential to consult with us or a qualified attorney who can provide advice tailored to your specific situation. Reliance on any information provided in these articles is solely at your own risk.
Increase Your Chance of Getting a
Trademark to 96%
Subscribe to Our Newsletter
Sign up to receive valuable information on E-Commerce and intellectual property
Jan 8, 2025 
